In-game misconduct:
CKEY: The Maggot Guy
Your Discord: themaggotguy
Offender’s CKEY: Marshmellow10 and Zoom9337
Offender’s In-Game Name (if relevant): N/A
Date: 2023-10-4
Round Number: 46098
Rules Broken (if relevant): N/A
Part of Admin/Mentor Conduct Broken (if relevant): This is a ruling disagreement
Incident Description: I’ve had the last name Finger for 3 years at this point and have played as Chuck or Charlie Finger for the last 3 years with no problems. This is because either @bloons3, who would’ve headmin at the time, or another admin, ruled that Finger was an acceptable last name around 2020-07-10. Finger isn’t an impossible last name, the guy who made Batman was Bill Finger, and the rarest mineral on Earth is named after a Dr. Larry Finger.
Moreover, I’ve had the name for years. It’s part of my identity, art of my character is my profile picture on all my social media and on steam (if I’m not doing a gimmick for TF2). I distinctly remember a comversation in the ahelps where I was allowed to keep the last name Finger for my character. And last year, (even though it was a short enough time) nobody had any issue with it while I was unbanned. I don’t see why I have to give it up now after all this time. Not another place has had an issue with it. If I sound mad, it’s because I am, but I’m mostly just kind of hurt. This is a name I care about, and it isn’t something ridiculous like Dorito, actual people have that as a last name. I really don’t see why I can’t keep it.
Additional Information: Marshmellow said he discussed it with other admins, but I’d really like confirmation on that, this really took me off guard.