They need an IC reason, not an OOC reason and they can’t just make something up and call it a reason. You stole from them, and that’s a valid reason.
That’s not the focus of this thread though - the focus is you broke the rules blatantly and your best excuse is ‘but they didn’t get in trouble’. You went out of your way to grief another player that had already been dealt with.
also litterally picking up disk talking to them about it then putting it down after loading it into machine becuase had been asked to put back is considered theft?
No if that’s what happened, and then the note is valid on the other player.
if i use your excuse again then if someone picks up a tool when on station i have every right to beat them to bloody pulp escalaitng it
No because lavaland escalation doesn’t apply to your fellow crew. Read more about it here: New Rulings